FERC Suspends PJM’s Backstop Procurement Five Months and PJM Pulls Its September 30 Auction

Key Facts
  • Suspension: five months
  • New effective date: February 28, 2027
  • Procurement target: 6,831 MW
  • Offer cap: $555/MW-day
  • NOVEC collateral estimate: $2 billion

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission accepted PJM Interconnection’s Reliability Backstop Procurement on September 29, then suspended it for five months. PJM pulled the auction it had planned to open on September 30. The grid operator had set a 6,831 MW procurement target to cover the shortfall from its 2028/2029 capacity auction. FERC set a new effective date of February 28, 2027, subject to refund and to further proceedings, according to PJM. PJM runs the grid for 13 Mid-Atlantic and Midwest states and the District of Columbia.

FERC did not approve the whole filing. It found three parts of the plan “may be unjust and unreasonable.” Those are cost allocation, the rules covering a transmission owner that exits PJM, and collateral requirements for load-serving entities. The agency offered a fix for each and told PJM to file them quickly. That would avoid a hearing.

Cost allocation drew the sharpest comment. PJM “did not adequately ensure that the procurement’s costs will be allocated to the customers who drive its need,” Commissioner See wrote in a concurrence. FERC proposed allocating the costs on updated load forecasts instead.

FERC Chairman Laura Swett was blunter. PJM filed at the last minute and left the agency no time “to rehabilitate the mess we received,” she wrote in a concurring statement. “This commission will not be forced into accepting a deeply flawed, eleventh-hour procurement mechanism with billion-dollar implications for consumers.”

The collateral finding carries a number. Northern Virginia Electric Cooperative told FERC it would have to post roughly $2 billion under PJM’s proposal, according to the decision. FERC accepted the collateral rules for power suppliers. It questioned the ones for load-serving entities.

FERC also struck PJM’s plan to let qualifying cooperatives and municipal utilities opt out of the procurement. That would discriminate against other load-serving entities with data centers in their footprints, the agency said.

The $555/MW-day offer cap survived, measured as a MW-weighted average over the delivery period. PJM had planned to take offers from September 30 through October 21, then pick winners between October 22 and December 2. A new timeline is not set. Jeffrey Shields, a PJM spokesman, said the order gives a “clear path” and that PJM intends to address the remaining concerns quickly.

Why It Matters

PJM failed to buy enough capacity in its last two base auctions to meet its reserve margin target. The backstop was the fix, and it now waits until the end of February at the earliest.

PJM had expected to publish backstop results before its regular capacity auction for the 2029/30 delivery year in early December. That order is gone. Bidders into the December auction will price it without knowing what the backstop bought.

The suspension also runs subject to refund, so the final cost allocation stays open. Load-serving entities in Northern Virginia and other data center clusters should track the collateral question first. The posting requirement one cooperative put on the record would be a balance-sheet event, not a market detail.

Critical Perspective

FERC accepted a 6,831 MW procurement and then suspended it for five months, so PJM holds a reliability tool that does not take effect until February 28, 2027. Northern Virginia Electric Cooperative told the Commission the collateral rules alone would make it post roughly $2 billion, which is the kind of number that reshapes who bids rather than how much capacity clears. PJM filed late enough that Chairman Laura Swett said the Commission had no time to rehabilitate the proposal, and a rushed refiling under section 205 invites the same objection twice. If the cost-allocation problem was clear enough for FERC to propose its own remedy inside the order, why was it not solved before the auction was due to open?

Sources

Related Coverage

Compliance Impact
✓StatusFiled
⏰TimelineFebruary 28, 2027

Related post