North Carolina Regulators Deny Duke Energy a 255 MW Gas Turbine Over Unverified Data-Center Load Growth

Key Facts
  • Capacity denied: 255 MW
  • Project cost: $584 million
  • Commission vote: 3-1 to deny
  • Share of Duke load growth from data centers: about 70 percent

The North Carolina Utilities Commission on September 18 denied Duke Energy a permit for a 255 MW simple-cycle combustion turbine in Richmond County. The commission put the project cost at $584 million. Staff testimony quoted in the order called that price tag “staggering” and “very expensive.” But the 23-page order turns on a narrower point than cost. The commission ruled that Duke’s own load forecast is not yet reliable enough to justify the plant. Most of the projected growth comes from data centers, and no contested proceeding has tested that demand.

Why It Matters

Utilities across the country are converting data-center interest into approved generation. This order breaks that chain at the permit stage. The commission accepted that Duke’s modeling projects significant load growth, then refused to act on it. “Any such anticipated load growth is insufficiently reliable for the Commission to act at this point,” the order states. WUNC reported that about 70 percent of Duke’s modeled growth comes from data centers, and that commissioners found staff had not vetted those numbers.

The commission also said Duke never showed how much of the turbine’s output would serve data centers. Nor did it show how those customers would pay for it.

Enforcement Reality

The vote was 3-1. Commissioners Bill Brawley, Tommy Tucker and Donald van der Vaart voted to deny. Floyd McKissick voted to grant and called the denial a serious error of judgment. John Gadja did not vote. The commission tied its timing to Duke’s pending 2025 Carbon Plan and Integrated Resource Plan case, where the load projections are still being litigated.

That sequencing is the enforceable part. A utility that wants a plant permit in North Carolina now has to survive the resource-plan record first.

The order also invokes the White House Ratepayer Protection Pledge. Duke and more than 200 other utilities signed it in March, promising not to shift data-center costs onto residential customers. The commission was explicit that the pledge does not replace the statutory CPCN standard. It then used the pledge anyway, as a measure of ratepayer impact. The record, it found, did not establish how the Smith turbine would honor that promise.

What Changed

Duke first proposed the Richmond County unit last fall as a peaking resource. It would be the sixth combustion turbine at the Sherwood H. Smith Jr. Energy Complex, near the South Carolina border. The commission has repeatedly approved Duke’s general buildout plans. Granting the plan and denying the specific permit is the distinction this order draws. A Duke spokesperson told Utility Dive the company is disappointed and is assessing next steps, and maintains the turbine is part of a least-cost path.

Duke told investors in February that its $103 billion capital plan was the largest on file at any regulated U.S. utility.

One caveat on the 70 percent figure. It reaches us through WUNC’s account of the commission’s reasoning, not from the order text. MGRID could not independently review the docket record behind it.

Critical Perspective

The commission put Duke’s turbine at $584 million and still refused to act on a load forecast that is roughly 70 percent data centers. The contrast with Texas is sharp, because the Public Utility Commission of Texas spent September making its own large-load queue cheaper to enter, dropping a proposed $50,000 per MW interconnection fee while ERCOT sits on a 474 GW backlog. North Carolina regulators have approved Duke’s general buildout plans repeatedly, so this is a procedural brake rather than a change of direction. If the Carolinas Resource Plan later blesses the same load forecast, what will actually have been tested?

Sources

Related Coverage

Compliance Impact
✓StatusFiled

Related post